Former Sherman Feed Store Sold
118 Kendrick St., Sherman was sold in December for $111,100. That is the location of Farmers Mill, which closed in 2019. P-J photo by Sara Holthouse
A closed feed mill in the western portion of the county has been sold.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Dec. 8-11.
During this time period, 118 Kendrick St., Sherman was sold for $111,100. That is the location of Farmers Mill, which closed in 2019.
In a separate sale, Chautauqua Inns, LTD sold 13 S. Erie St., Mayville to Chautauqua Properties, LLC of Mayville for $125,000. That is the location of the business Uptown Mall.
Since 2023, Chautauqua Inns, LTD has sold a number of commercial properties in Mayville including: 11, 17, 19, 21, 28, 43, 45, 51, 186 and 188 S. Erie St. and 15 Water St. Those are current or former storefront businesses and/or restaurants.
From Dec. 8-11 there were seven sales that were $250,000 or higher. They are as follows:
– 137 Chautauqua Escapes Ave., North Harmony sold for $995,000.
– 4200 Beck Road, Ellery sold for $500,000.
– 156 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony sold for $410,000.
– Home 8434, Highlands II Condominium, French Creek sold for $400,000.
– 150 Sea Lion Drive, Mayville sold for $325,000.
– 10595 Dunkirk town sold for $272,000.
– 56 Briggs St., Lakewood sold for $265,000.
Overall, from Dec. 8-11 there were 65 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
Andre Persaud and Deborah Briggs sold 10595 Dunkirk town to Frederick and Beverly Krywy for $272,000.
Brenda Strasser sold a parcel on Falconer Street, Jamestown to Abdulla Abuhamra for $500.
Tammy Mowrey and Brenda Meyer sold 10609 Lakewood Drive, Dunkirk town to Mark and Erin Rountree for $169,500.
Jacqueline Penhollow sold 15 Wilson Place, Jamestown to Mark Ella for $49,500.
Nicholas Kubiszyn sold 147 Lambert Ave., Fredonia to Mitchell Laurie for $152,000.
Richard Wilcox sold a parcel on Red Wing Road, Chautauqua town to Edward Finley for $7,500.
Christopher and Elizabeth Fallon sold 156 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony to Daniel and Rebecca Goldie for $410,000.
Tracy and Ronald Penn sold 849 Hopper Road, Hanover to Matthew and Angela Sevilla for $126,500.
Paul and Marsha Holst sold 150 Sea Lion Drive, Mayville to Cynthia and Peter Johnson for $325,000.
A referee for Kenlyn Scalf sold 172 Stowe St., Jamestown to Thomas Bailey Jr. for $48,700.
Rosemarie Bottomley sold 7 Patterson St., Mayville to Alex and Haley Reardon for $100,000.
A referee for Toni Miller, Steve Brown, Kirstina Farmer and Michelle Pacheo sold 346 Willard St., Jamestown to U.S. Bank Trust Company for $60,000.
Henry and Carole Link sold a parcel on Highland Avenue and Webster Road, Portland to Delsey Properties, Inc. of Grand Island for $18,000.
Christine Zinter-Chahin sold 137 Chautauqua Escapes Ave., North Harmony to Jennifer Panzica for $995,000.
Lynn Ford, Mark Ford, and Brett Simon sold 1955 Ruttenbur Road, Arkwright to Isaac and Mary Habermehl for $56,000.
Saul Jr. and Eileen Santiago sold Home 8434, Highlands II Condominium, French Creek to Raymond and Sherrie Fischer for $400,000.
A referee for Andrew Laury sold 56 Briggs St., Lakewood to Thomas Turner for $265,000.
John and Donna Mackenzie sold 4200 Beck Road, Ellery to Triumphant Life Church of Erie, Pa. for $500,000.
Brenda Perks sold 346 West Main St., Falconer to Nathaniel Fleming for $45,000.
The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of Jean Pierre Lachapelle sold 105 Charles St., Jamestown to Sean Vanni for $60,000.
Stephen and Dawn Jusko sold 8273 Fredonia-Stockton Road, Pomfret to Stephen and Tiffany Jusko for $150,000.
Chelsea and Amber Fisher sold 3173 Open Meadows Road, North Harmony to Chelsea Fisher for $75,000.
Cockaigne Holdings, LLC of Fredonia sold a parcel on Farrington Hollow Road, Cherry Creek to Dannie and Katie Wengerd for $195,000.
John Jr. and Mindie McCarthy sold 1014 Poland Center Road, Poland to Deborah Carlson for $120,000.
Zachary and Valerie Emmick sold 24 Park St., Brocton to Adam Tanner for $162,500.
Steven Smithers sold 106 Chestnut St., Westfield to Jared and Jenna Hepp for $180,200.
B Grabias, LLC of Dunkirk sold 535 Deer St., Dunkirk to 527 Deer Street, LLC of Dunkirk for $35,000.
Chautauqua Inns, LTD of Mayville sold 13 S. Erie St., Mayville to Chautauqua Properties, LLC of Mayville for $125,000.
Joshua Brown sold 58 North Erie St., Mayville to Ramon Gurubel for $70,000.
Robert and Ann Beckman sold 7833 Cummings Road, Stockton to John and Linda Burton for $88,285.
Robert Beckman sold 7833 Cummings Road, Stockton to Joseph Mikula for $4,000.






