Breaking News
Local Sports

Shotguns, rifles, crossbows: the changing face of deer hunting

By Forrest Fisher 5 min read

For generations, deer hunters across Western New York headed into the woods carrying shotguns. It was simply the accepted way of hunting big game in many parts of New York State where rifle use was restricted by law.

For many longtime hunters, that familiar shotgun remains their firearm of choice today.

Why not? A dependable shotgun, properly sighted in and loaded with the right ammunition, can still be an excellent deer-hunting tool.

Since those old days, hunting regulations have evolved, and so has ammunition technology.

So, over the years, New York lawmakers gradually expanded rifle privileges for big-game hunting on a county-by-county basis. Chautauqua County joined the list in 2011, initially allowing rifle use in designated areas south of Route 20. Wyoming County’s rifle authorization, initially established in 2011, became permanent in 2013. Cattaraugus and Allegheny Counties have also long permitted rifle hunting.

Today, hunters have more choices, although restrictions remain. Rifles are not permitted for big-game hunting in Erie and Monroe counties -- but crossbows are, and certain geographic exceptions apply elsewhere. Of course, we hunters should always consult the latest NYSDEC regulations and maps before heading afield.

Shotgun technology has come a long way.

Traditional 12-gauge, 2 3⁄4-inch rifled slugs remain popular, but today’s hunters can choose from a wide selection of ammunition, including 3-inch (magnum) and 3 1⁄2-inch (super-magnum) shells where firearms are chambered to accept them. Sixteen- and 20-gauge options also offer effective alternatives. Deer slug types include Foster (rifled solid lead), Brenneke (hard lead alloy) -- both of these for smooth bore barrels, and Sabot (lead, copper or polymer tipped) inside a plastic sleeve engineered for rifled barrels. The newer slug designs offer improved accuracy, expansion and weight retention, depending on the firearm and ammunition combination.

Myself, I have many favorite rifles, but my favorite short distance deer hunting tool is still my Remington 1100 shotgun. I like the balance, the feel, and the total accuracy of this firearm with a saboted slug fired through the Hastings rifled barrel with a 1.5-4X Leupold scope. They call it a "tack-driver." All the slugs on a target within a half inch at 75 yards. Shotguns in WNY are a proven deer hunting tradition.

With a rifle, there are many more choices and greater range options. Modern centerfire rifles offer hunters a broad selection of calibers, bullet weights and projectile designs. Traditional lead-core bullets, bonded bullets, hollow points, solid and expanding copper bullets all have their place.

Rifles generally offer greater effective range than shotguns, but that does not make them the right choice for every hunting situation. Terrain, visibility, shooting distances, experience and familiarity with the firearm should all influence a hunter’s decision. Sitting on the edge of a field or forest edge with 200- yard visibility? Then a rifle is a good choice.

Regardless of firearm choice, hunters must know their equipment, practice before the season, identify their target and what lies beyond it, and never take an uncertain shot.

Of course, we have talked about this all week. One very important consideration is what’s going into your freezer? So there is another development every deer hunter should consider: the growing availability of lead-free ammunition.

The DEC encourages hunters to consider non-lead projectiles, particularly solid copper and copper-alloy bullets and slugs. Unlike traditional lead ammunition, these harder projectiles generally retain more of their original weight and are less likely to fragment extensively upon impact.

Why does that matter? Small lead fragments can spread through surrounding tissue and find their way into packaged venison, particularly ground meat. Some particles are too small to see or remove. Lead is a recognized neurotoxin, and reducing unnecessary exposure is a worthwhile consideration for anyone feeding family and friends with harvested game.

Since there are many non-lead choices available for both rifles and shotguns, this is an increasingly practical option regardless of a hunter’s preferred firearm. Hunters can consult the DEC’s ammunition resources and check with local sporting-goods dealers for compatible products.

Ultimately, deer hunting is about much more than the firearm carried into the woods. It is about tradition, responsible decisions, conservation and putting safe, healthy food on the table.

Whether you are carrying your grandpa’s trusted shotgun or a modern centerfire rifle, today’s hunter has more options than ever. Yes, there can be resultantly related confusion, hunting camp and your local firearm supplier can help sort that out. Respecting tradition while embracing improvements in ammunition technology is a winning combination for hunters, wildlife and future generations.

Gotta love the outdoors.

Outdoor Calendar

Nov. 20: Last day of the NY Southern Zone Early Archery Big Game Season, ends 30 minutes after sunset.

Nov. 21: Opening Day of NYS Southern Zone Big Game Regular Firearm Season, runs through Dec. 13. Starts 30 minutes before sunrise.

Nov. 21-22: NY Concealed Carry Class, Bear Lake Rod and Gun, 4391 Cassadaga-Stockton Road, Stockton, limited seats, register at 716-410-6692.

Starting at /week.