Breaking News
Local Commentaries

They killed the wrong woman

By Fred Larson 4 min read

The famous American Presidential historian, Doris Kearns Goodwin, has opined recently that the beginning of the public's rejection of President Trump and his MAGA movement was the killing of Renee Good on the streets of Minneapolis by ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement).

Until that killing, the public had largely supported Trump's argument in the 2024 Prsidential campaign that the Biden-Harris Administration had failed to protect the Southern border from significant illegal immigration.

The Trump Administration claimed in 2025 that it was going after "the worst of the worst" of illegal immigrants; those that had committed rape, murder or other serious crimes.

Then on January 7,2026, at 9:39 am during a Federal immigration enforcement operation in Minneapolis (1,400 miles from the Southern border) known as "Operation Metro Surge", instead of an ICE agent shooting an illegal immigrant who was the "worst of the worst", the ICE agent fired 3 shots into a Honda Pilot, killing a white, blonde, female, U.S. citizen, named Renee Good, a mother of 3 who had just dropped off her 6-year-old at school.

How America got to the killing of Renee Good really begins with Trump's 2016 Presidential campaign when he went beyond promising tough immigration enforcement at our Southern border to promising to remove an estimated 11,000,000 undocumented immigrants

During a Presidential Primary debate, Trump said: "We have at least 11 million people in this country that came in illegally. They will go out."

Newly elected President Trump in 2017 made Stephen Miller a key figure in immigration policy, including the "family separation policy." (This month President Trump made Mr. Miller, 41, the White House Chief of Staff who the New York Times described as "the most powerful policy staff member in the modern history of the Presidency").

The Trump Administration in 2017, led by Mr. Miller, intentionally began separating children from their undocumented immigrant parents with the belief that such a cruel tactic would dissuade others from Mexico or Central America from daring to cross the border.

This "family separation policy" was a tactic that many Americans rejected. Joe Biden's opposition to the "family separation policy" contributed to his defeat of Donald Trump in the 2020 Presidential election.

As too often happens in politics, when Republicans go too far to the right, for example, Democrats respond by going too far to the left

Newly elected Joe Biden's biggest political mistake was responding to the overreach of the Trump Administration by not vigorously controlling the Southern border. Cruelty by one side led to leniency by the other. Neither side exhibited "common sense" on the importance of securing the Southern border, in a lawful but humane way.

Trump then defeated Biden's Vice President, Kamala Harris, in 2024 on the issues of immigration (not securing the Southern border) and inflation (coming out of al the economic dislocations resulting from the Covid Pandemic).

The killing of Renee Good by ICE in January 2026, caused many Americans to question if Ice was truly going after the "worst of the worst" or was ICE rounding up people to meet some quota.

In 2026 there were credible reports that ICE agents were to aim for 3,000 arrests per day or roughly 19,000 arrests per week, or about 1,000,000 persons in a year.

According to reports this year from ICE itself, 70% of individuals in ICE detention have no criminal record at all.

Many Americans, after the shooting death of Renee Good, began questioning the nature and training of the thousands of recently hired ICE agents.

Just this September ICE was preparing to have a hiring surge that would bring in 5,000 new employees by the end of 2026. The New York Times reported that a similar hiring surge in 2025 resulted in undervetted officers initially being let in and then removed as ICE had skipped basic checks for the new recruits.

Many Americans began to see the actions of ICE, far from the Southern border, as both cruel and incompetent. Americans often do not think about it, but we expect our Federal government to be competent in its essential functions in keeping us safe, whether through law enforcement on the ground or the government's air traffic control system in the skies.

What could have done more to destroy the Trump Administration's repeated public relations message that ICE was after the "worst of the worst" than to shoot dead an American citizen, in broad daylight on the streets of Minneapolis, in her own car, a woman named "Good"

Fred Larson was an attorney in private practice from 1977-2014 and served as a Jamestown City Court Judge from 2014-2021.

Starting at /week.