Breaking News
Local Commentaries

The meaning of a free press

By Rolland Kidder 3 min read

I have been confounded, over the years, by the criticism of what is called "the mainstream media." It is a word coined, I believe, to convey the idea that everything we read in the press is distorted or changed as to become a lie and to undercut the common good.

What is the mainstream media? Is it tabloid journalism, like the NY Post or the NY Daily News? Is it entertainment news like FOX News or MSNBC? Likely these do not constitute what is meant by "mainstream."

So that brings us back to what is in between the extremes--names like the NY Times, the Washington Post, the Wall St. Journal, the Associated Press, Reuters and probably the primary TV networks. Whatever you want to call them, such organs of the press are what have historically given us a factual portrayal of what is going on in the world.

Such news outlets can have an editorial bias, but, as to news, what they try to do is give us the facts. If it is not factual, they can be sued for libel. Truth has always been the best defense against libel.

The best test, of course, for what we call a "free press" (one of our constitutional rights) is whether the press will have the courage to print or proclaim news that may go against powerful interests. The litmus test for that was likely the Washington Post's publication of the facts about the Watergate break-in during the Nixon administration.

In that light, I found it reassuring when the New York Times, (deemed by some to only be a voice for Democrats) came out two weeks before this last election and divulged the fact that a concerted effort had been made by some Democrats to add another "Daniel Sullivan" to the ballot in Alaska where the incumbent Republican Senator Daniel Sullivan was running for reelection.

What? A Democratic newspaper uncovering political shenanigans that will hurt Democrats? Yes…that is what happened. It is the kind of news that would have been buried at some political news venues.

When I read it, my heart jumped a beat. This is what the free press is all about. Gathering facts, disclosing them, and being a check on our political system.

In fairness, the article recited the fact that similar tactics had been used by Republicans in the past in Alaska where there is a system of ranked-choice voting. Yet, two wrongs don't make a right even if the practice is technically legal. In the end, the Democratic candidate won despite the controversy caused by the article.

But you have to give a "mainstream media" newspaper credit for divulging all of this before a very critical election which could have decided the majority in the U.S. Senate. Trying to confuse voters is not in the public interest, and the Times published the truth about what was going on.

Where would we be without a free press? That is one of the reasons I worry about President Trump's attempt to ban news organizations who criticize him from the White House and Presidential press pool.

That is, of course, a battle that will never end. Presidents have never liked the scrutiny of the press. But, that is the very reason freedom of the press is protected by the Constitution. One reason we still have a democracy is because we have a free press always trying to dig up the facts and tell the truth no matter who the politician or party is.

Rolland Kidder is a Stow resident.

Starting at /week.