Breaking News
In Our Opinion

Once again, an old idea turns up again in Jamestown

2 min read

Jamestown assessor Heather Young-Deyell suggested during a recent budget presentation that more tax-exempt properties should make voluntary payments-in-lieu-of-taxes.

We don't disagree. But we also know it would be foolish to put too many eggs in that particular basket.

Jamestown has had a tax-exemption problem for decades, with 39% of taxable property in Jamestown currently listed as tax exempt. To their credit, some tax-exempt property owners in Jamestown do pay voluntary PILOT payments. City PILOT agreements accounted for $326,320.54 in 2025, are budgeted to be $355,296 in 2026 and are budgeted for $370,082 in 2027. That doesn’t include PILOT payments from the city BPU, which totaled $4,314,851.41 in 2025, are budgeted to be $4,544,578 in 2026 and are budgeted for $4,749,999 in 2027.

It's been more than 20 years since former councilman Jim McElrath mounted a similar push to get more tax-exempt properties to voluntarily make payments to the city in exchange for services received – particularly police, fire and plowing.

A few non-profits signed up. Most did not. And in fairness, there are a good many nonprofits that are facing their own financial issues.

There are 14,457 taxable parcels in Jamestown, with 1,129 considered wholly exempt (7.8%). Hospital-owned property accounts for 16 parcels valued at $39,338,300. Does anyone expect UPMC Chautauqua, given the state of health care, to make a voluntary PILOT payment? There are 129 either clergy or religious parcels totaling $28,713,700 in city taxable assessment. Many churches have either closed or merged in the past couple of decades, with others like Holy Apostles Parish narrowly avoiding closure. There are 815 properties with some sort of a veterans exemption totaling $238,750. We don’t see anyone stepping on that particular live wire in the month of November.

It doesn't do any harm to ask. In fact it's a request the city should periodically make. We agreed with McElrath's push two decades ago. But we also know that much like the push to bring more conferences into the city, this is an old idea that didn't pay off with bountiful rewards the first time around. Those who have been around a while remember some of these efforts coming and going with little benefit. So we don't expect much out of asking non-profits to pay the city voluntarily even though they do receive city services.

Building city tax revenue is going to come from building the taxable assessment, not squeezing non-profits.

Starting at /week.