Trending
A series of charges filed against an area man over the course of roughly three weeks shines a light on a bail reform issue that the state Legislature should address during the coming legislative session – though with Democratic supermajorities in the Assembly and Senate we have no expectation of change coming.
One of the frustrations for local police officers is arresting the same people multiple times on the same day, or over a series of days, because people charged with what are generally deemed nuisance crimes must be released with appearance tickets by judges. And a review of the charges – Petit larceny, second-degree harassment, trespass, resisting arrest, second-degree obstruction of governmental administration, second-degree criminal contempt, second-degree harassment, third-degree burglary, third-degree criminal mischief, second-degree menacing and fourth-degree criminal possession of a weapon – filed from Oct. 15 through Nov. 7 against the Falconer man didn't rise to the level of being bail eligible.
There is no escalator clause in state law that allows judges to set bail in when several nuisance cases take place over a short period of time. Under New York’s amended bail statutes, a non-violent felony or a Class A misdemeanor becomes bail-eligible if the defendant is charged with a felony or a Class A misdemeanor that involves harm to an identifiable person or property. Bail can be set if, when that person is released on their own recognizance or via an appearance ticket for that initial charge, while the first case is still pending, is arrested again for a separate felony or Class A misdemeanor that also involves harm to an identifiable person or property. That didn't happen in this recent set of incidents.
Nuisance crimes aren't always victimless. A person in Jamestown was threatened with a hammer at a downtown business. A store employee in Falconer was allegedly threatened while simply being at work. Store employees, again just doing their jobs, were threatened in another incident. An order of protection against another store employee was allegedly violated. And a fourth group of store employees were threatened.
It makes little sense, in our opinion, for already overburdened police departments to respond to nuisance crimes when someone has been arraigned and released on prior alleged offenses. It makes little sense to have police officers taking people to Mayville for centralized arraignment more than once in the same day, wasting both their time and the judge's time. Bail reform is supposed to help those who spend time in jail because they couldn't afford bail. It should not allow nuisance crimes to build on each other
The law should recognize that most people who are charged with nuisance crimes don't reoffend quickly. But those who do should be bail eligible at some point even if their charges never rise above a nuisance level. These are the types of situations that people cite when they talk about problems with bail reform in New York state. State lawmakers can address it, but we won't hold our breath.
.