Breaking News
In Our Opinion

Jamestown’s Finances Were Bad, But Not Control Board-Level Bad

3 min read

Jamestown taxpayers have had every right to be concerned with the city's financial health for some three decades now.

Much has been said by mayors and council members about concerns over the long-term financial health of the city as costs for staff and benefits increased while the city's ability to raise taxes was limited by the state's constitutional tax limit. For a few years the city was using its Board of Public Utilities to balance the budget, followed by balancing the budget with an additional $1 million a year of additional state aid through former Gov. Andrew Cuomo.

But one thing the city didn't seem close to, at least according to the state Comptroller's Office and the state Legislature, was a state-imposed control board. The possibility of a control board was brought up in response to a question posed by The Post-Journal to mayoral candidates Kim Ecklund and Mayor Eddie Sundquist.

"When I became mayor in 2020, the city's financial outlook was in dire straits," Sundquist said in a written response to a question. "We were on the verge of a control board, our residents were overtaxed, and our legacy costs were mounting. Since then, I have gotten our financial house in order, with the largest fund balance in decades, have kept taxes flat with conservative budgeting, despite massive inflation, all while offering more services and public protection, at no cost to the local taxpayer."

Sundquist is right that city residents were overtaxed and legacy costs were mounting. Some of those legacy costs are still mounting, while Sundquist led an effort to decrease some of those legacy costs by shifting a majority of city retirees from city-backed health insurance to Medicaid. Sundquist -- and the City Council -- have done some good things over the past three years with the budget, though their cause has also been helped by federal stimulus funding that gave the city the financial wiggle room to make investments it hadn't been able to afford in years prior.

Imposition of a control board, though, is a different matter. Sundquist is right that the city's fund balance had been dwindling from 2010 to 2016, the year before additional state aid helped the city record back-to-back budget surpluses, reaching a low of $1,567,438 in 2016. But the state Comptroller's Office's Fiscal Stress rankings never indicated the city was in fiscal stress despite a two-year blip where the city's fiscal stress rating did increase. We noted in this space our disagreement with the way the rankings are compiled, but they remain an influential ranking amongst state policy makers who would rely on the comptroller's analysis to decide whether or not a control board was actually necessary in Jamestown. Most importantly, legislation to implement a control board was never introduced in the state Legislature, which is how a control board is actually implemented.

In short, a control board wasn't a serious consideration unless things got much, much worse. If action had not been taken to change the city's trajectory -- not just during Sundquist's administration but administrations prior -- the city's fund balance could have been exhausted. But a control board is a worst-case scenario that hasn't been a real worry for Jamestown for two decades.

The notion of a control board may very well have been the mayor's opinion, but the mention of a control board never happened at the state level.

Starting at /week.