Trending
When Jamestown City Council members decided to build a new fleet maintenance facility on Washington Street, the project was supposed to cost $2.1 million.
Now, a scant two years later, the $2.1 million puppy has grown into a $4.7 million version of Clifford the Big Red Dog -- and some council members are concerned how much bigger the big red dog is going to get.
We admit hindsight is 20-20, but should Jamestown have really taken on construction of a new fleet maintenance building on Washington Street at a time of high inflation? It's not as if inflation wasn't a problem in 2021. Inflation, again much like Clifford the Big Red Dog, has only gotten bigger over time. The city chose to build in perhaps the worst public construction period in decades.
How much has inflation hit the fleet maintenance facility's budget. The building was initially billed as $2.1 million when the City Council approved purchasing the Washington Street property in June 2021. That $2.1 million included $400,000 to purchase the property from Timothy Shults. The city had received a $1 million grant from the state Financial Restructuring Board, so the construction costs were, in 2021, supposed to be $1.1 million. That amount would have fit easily within the city's $28.3 million American Rescue Plan Act allocation.
So, armed with that knowledge, council members decided to buy the cute red puppy brought to them by Mayor Eddie Sundquist and his leadership team. By July 2022 council members were told the price was going to be between $4 and $5 million before approving $4,502,187 in construction contracts for the building. The contracts didn't appear on a council agenda for the one July 2022 work session that was held, nor was there a public discussion of the project at a work session. That little red puppy had become a big red dog, with no public discussion of how to pay for the big red dog's appetite.
The lone mention of the project in 2022, before the $4.5 million in construction contracts were approved, was $232,300 to buy a pre-engineered metal building for the project -- with that money to either come from the $1 million state grant or a bond act. That takes the total project budget to at least $4.734,487. The big red dog apparently needed a chew toy.
At that point, no one should be under any illusion that the building's cost is anything less than at least $4.5 million. Yet, because the project's financing is unclear, and there wasn't formal approval of a project scope other than the contracts that were approved in a piecemeal fashion, City Council Public Works Committee chairman Randy Daversa, R-At Large, said just this week that he thought the project was $2.8 million. The $2.8 million is what the city has drawn from the bond for the fleet maintenance building project, not the total project cost. Note, though, that between the June 2021 and July 2022 voting sessions when the first step toward the fleet maintenance building were taken and the contracts were approved, the public still hadn't been told in any certain terms what the cost would be and, more importantly, how the project was financed. All the public knew was that four contracts had been approved.
The costs for this project have been a moving target since it was first public discussed in 2021. If any of our readers were building a new buildng on their property, they'd have been sure to know the costs and financing before one nail was hammered into a board.
But that isn't what happened here. Once the first step was taken, the council and Sundquist's team have stumbled forward without asking the two most pivotal questions of all -- how much do we want to spend and is this a necessary project right now? It doesn't appear those questions have come up at all since June 2021. That was two years and roughly $3.9 million ago.
Of course, that's what happens when you buy a little red puppy and assume it will stay little, red and cute forever. Parents know you have to plan for contingencies. It's too late to do so after you've bought the little red puppy -- or in this case, the nice $1.1 million fleet maintenance facility.
Jamestown's little red puppy has outgrown its dog house and chewed up everybody's shoes. It's a little too late to ask taxpayers now if they even wanted this dog in the first place.