Lobbyists mount push against Food Safety, Chemical Disclosure bill
Trending
Businesses and labor unions are opposing legislation delivered recently to Gov. Kathy Hochul that would ban three food additives and require food companies to disclose food ingredients they designate as "generally recognized as safe."
The legislation (A1556G/S.1239F) was passed 106-32 in the state Assembly with Assemblyman Andrew Molitor and Assemblyman Joe Sempolinski both voting in favor. The state Senate vote was unanimous with state Sen. George Borrello, R-Sunset Bay, voting in favor.
The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act will require food companies to report to New York regulators any food ingredients they designate in-house as “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS) and decline to disclose to the FDA, along with the scientific basis for considering them safe. The state Department of Agriculture and Markets will then make that information publicly available.
Assemblywoman Dr. Anna Kelles, D-Ithaca, and Sen. Brian Kavanaugh, D-New York City, said the legislation will close a longstanding federal loophole, which they said is sometimes referred to as secret GRAS, that has allowed manufacturers to keep potentially harmful chemicals secret from regulators, independent scientists and consumers.
Robert F. Kennedy, federal Health and Human Services secretary, directed the FDA in March 2025 to explore rulemaking that could eventually close the GRAS loophole, Kelles and Kavanaugh said the process could take years
to complete, if it happens at all, and faces stiff opposition from the food industry that has blocked federal legislation and regulatory accountability in the past.
In addition to addressing the “secret GRAS” loophole, the New York legislation also prohibits the manufacture and sale of food products containing three harmful additives: Red Dye 3, which has been linked to cancer and behavioral problems in children; potassium bromate, linked to cancer and thyroid disease; and propylparaben, linked to hormone and reproductive system harm. California and the European Union have already taken steps to ban these additives in all or nearly all foods, and a federal ban on Red Dye 3 will take effect next year.
"The fact that the industry has put so much effort into blocking us from seeing what’s in our food supply should in and of itself be a concern," Kelles said on the Assembly floor prior to the April 21 floor vote. "We’re simply saying, just tell us what’s in our food. We want to take care of our children. We want to make sure that they’re healthy. And if we don’t know what is in our food supply, you’re taking away our power and our right to protect our children and to protect our families. We are saying we simply want to know. That’s all this is doing. With the foods, the chemicals that we are banning, as I’ve stated, there are cost-competitive alternatives. They have been banded by other states and other countries, supply already exists, formulations already exist with the alternatives in them. This will not be a profound burden on the companies and if they are saying that it is, then they are putting their profits over the health of our people. We should find that suspect."
The legislation was delivered to Hochul for evaluation last week. Many of the organizations that lobbied legislators to defeat the legislation are also lobbying Hochul to veto the legislation on the grounds that the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act will increase consumer costs and create a reporting regime that would require extensive paperwork and reviews prior to selling or offering the GRAS ingredients for sale.
“The bill creates a duplicative state review process for food ingredients that already meet federal safety standards, adding new costs, confusion and red tape for grocers, convenience stores, neighborhood markets and the suppliers we depend on,” states a letter being sent to the governor on behalf of more than 100 small grocers, deli owners, bakeries, convenience stores and other businesses, according to the Albany Times Union. “New York should be lifting up the small businesses that power its success, not burdening us and our customers with higher costs.”
Another coalition, made up of dozens of business organizations, chambers of commerce and food and beverage associations, wrote a separate letter to Hochul urging her to veto the legislation. Opponents also say the proposed state action undermines the federal Food and Drug Administration. Hochul is also receiving pressure from organized labor to reject the legislation.