LLC-owned abandoned properties remain concern for city
Trending
Abandoned properties and neglectful landlords remain a problem in the city, especially those owned by LLCs.
The city's Department of Development has been working on these issues for a number of years, and the issues were brought up again during Monday's housing committee meeting.
A few city residents spoke during the meeting about their concerns with abandoned properties both around the city and in their own neighborhoods. Crystal Surdyk, city development director, said part of the complications that come with the abandoned properties owned by LLCs is that the department first has to figure out who is behind the LLCs, and then they have to be able to prove it. This is something that can be difficult to do.
"Now that we've been working at it for a couple of years we're starting to figure out how to make that case in court," Surdyk said. "Sometimes you can even get them to admit that they own the LLC. It doesn't happen often but it does happen. So, (we have to) make that case and be able to prove the connection between the individual and the LLC."
Additionally, Surdyk said the state now requires that when an individual registers for a new LLC they have to list who the primary responsible party is for that LLC. Like the city, Surdyk added, the state has limits to how much it can enforce, so there is still no guarantee when an LLC is looked up that a name will be associated with it. But, she said, it has gotten better, because there did not used to be a law.
Bringing the actual person into court is the hardest part, Surdyk said, but once that person is brought into court then that case is able to continue even if the person tries to close their LLC.
"When you use your shield as a sword and we can demonstrate that, that changes the conversation," Surdyk said. "It's not going to be easy by any stretch, but we have had some successes and we have to keep trying."
Something else that the city is working on in regards to LLCs, potentially at the county level but for sure at the state level, is proposing legislation to help the issue. Surdyk noted that Jamestown is not the only municipality dealing with LLCs, as it is something that affects people around the country and world.
"Something that we are going to be proposing is, and I don't have it totally formulated yet, basically looking at proposing legislation that gives us the ability to -- especially during tax auction time as that would probably be the primary use -- to not accept a bid from just the lowest builder using the criteria that they normally use," Surdyk said. "But, also, giving us the ability to, just because someone wants to buy a property, they don't necessarily get to buy a property. If they have a persistent history of unpaid taxes and they have a persistent history of code violations they should not just be allowed to continue that behavior."
The city is looking into how to put a proposal for that together with the correct language, and what the best course of action to propose that at the state level would be. Jamestown would not propose it on their own either, Surdyk said, and the city's fellow municipalities in the county and the state would come together to propose it as well.
"I've had this conversation with other people, my peers in other cities, and it's the same thing," Surdyk said. "I think (it needs to be) bringing a group of people to Albany and saying we've got to do something about this."
Surdyk also presented the housing committee with an updated list of housing demolitions and costs in the city, with a note that more are expected to come down in the next few weeks.