Trending
MAYVILLE - County lawmakers say they are unable to restrict the county's Industrial Development Agency from offering tax breaks to data centers.
However the Chautauqua County Legislature is looking to draft different legislation to express its opposition to such a move.
In October, the county legislature's Democratic Caucus proposed a resolution entitled "Adopting a Uniform Tax Exemption Policy… Providing that the Chautauqua County Industrial Development Agency Shall Not Consent to Real Property Tax Exemptions, Mortgage Recording Tax Exemptions, or Sales and Use Tax Exemptions for Data Center Projects."
The caucus did not submit the resolution to committee for review and instead sought an immediate vote. However at the legislature meeting, the county's Legal Department questioned the legality of the resolution. The resolution was sent to committee for further discussion.
At the legislature's Audit and Control Committee meeting Thursday, members appeared resigned to the fact that the resolution won't stand up in court.
"If this were legal, I would support it wholeheartedly, and I would add wind turbines, solar farms, and BESS (Battery Energy Storage Systems), but I gather this is not. We've consulted with the experts and as written it's not legal," Legislator Fred Johnson, R-Westfield, said. "I will vote against it, but I would welcome a redraft in a form that is legal."
Legislator Bob Scudder, R-Fredonia, agreed.
"My understanding is it's not legal, so I'm going to vote against it," he said.
According to the state Department of Taxation and Finance website, an Industrial Development Agency is a public benefit corporation established under state law (such as in New York) to promote local economic growth, job creation, and business investment.
Because of this, IDA legal counsel Milian Tyler questioned the resolution's authority, to which county attorney Nathan Harp acknowledged.
Legislator Tom Nelson, D-Jamestown, is one of the original co-sponsors of the resolution. During Thursday's committee meeting, Nelson said he has a lot of concerns about data centers.
"There's a number of issues that surround it - electricity demand, the water consumption, the noise, the environmental impacts overall," he said.
But even with those issues, he said there's no point in approving the resolution if it’s not legal.
Scudder said a few months ago he asked the county Law Department if the legislature could put a moratorium on building data centers, Battery Energy Storage Systems, wind turbines and large solar projects, but was told that's not something they have authority over.
Instead, that's something towns, villages and cities can ban or permit.
Legislature Chairman Pierre Chagnon said that's because that's a zoning issue.
"The county has no authority for zoning," he said.
Chagnon did note the resolution introduced in October was focused on banning Payment In Lieu Of Taxes agreements.
Even though the county legislature can't force the county IDA from offering PILOTs, it has in the past requested the IDA not to give them.
"What I would suggest to the sponsors of the resolution or the (Audit and Control) committee is that they might want to think about bringing forth another resolution in the future, urging the IDA to restrict, or not issue PILOTs for some of these projects. I think that's worthy of discussion, especially if it goes through committee," Chagnon said.
Johnson suggested the legislature use more "teeth" in a similar resolution.
"Rather than just urging, basically if you then go against our urges, don't come asking us for any money for anything down the road. The same thing goes for towns and villages. ... We can't tell you what to do in zoning, but if you go down this track, don't be asking for help when you're in a jam," he said.
Legislator Dan Pavlock, R-Ellington, who chairs the Audit and Control Committee meeting, said he will work with the county Law Department and draft something new, as well as speak to the county IDA and county Planning Department so they understand what the legislature's desires are.
"We can do it as a team effort and hopefully that will work," he said.
The Audit and Control Committee formally rejected the tabled resolution. The full legislature will still be required to vote on it at its next meeting Wednesday.