Sales Include 2 $1M Properties
The Sinclairville Post Office building was sold in November for about $668,000. P-J photo by Gregory Bacon
A company that owns some post office buildings in Chautauqua County has purchased another.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Nov. 10-14.
During this time period, APIF-New York, LLC purchased 11 Main St., Sinclairville for $668,416. That is the address of the Sinclairville Post Office.
In 2024, APIF-New York, LLC purchased the Sherman Post Office and in 2023 it purchased the Lakewood Post Office.
In other news, there were two sales during this time period that topped $1 million.
6007 Tinkertown Road, in the town of Chautauqua sold for $2,912,750.
9247 Ravlin Hill Road, and three other parcels on Ravlin Hill and Bush roads, all in French Creek, were sold to 4 Jacks Dairy, LLC for $1,472,000. The three parcels without addresses are labeled as field crop and vacant farmland, and total around 150 acres.
Including the sales previously mentioned, from Nov. 10-14 there were nine sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 6483 Sandalwood Lane, Chautauqua town sold for $590,000.
– 22 Parkside St., Mayville sold for $340,000.
– 8011 Milestrip Road, Villenova sold for $285,350.
– 4325 Leach Hill Road, Ellington sold for $280,000.
– 9178 Walden Road, Pomfret sold for $275,000.
– Condominium Unit No. E-7, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua town sold for $250,000.
Overall, from Nov. 10-14 there were 75 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
Leonard and Mary Wienckowski sold 8805 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret to Corey and Melissa Leone for $140,000.
Emanuel and Miriam Miller sold 8011 Milestrip Road, Villenova to Lewis and Malinda Hostetler for $285,350.
Secretary of Veterans Affairs sold 48 Blanchard St., Jamestown to Tuyen Bui for $20,000.
Rebecca and Austin Elkins sold 689 Clymer Hill Road, Clymer to Mark and Shelly Einink for $140,000.
The executor of the Estate of Sherwood Durnell sold 2192 Third Ave., Busti to Guaman Investments, LLC of Lakewood for $140,800.
Allesandro Difrangia and John Wroblewski sold a 60-acre parcel on Gilmore Road, French Creek to West Wind Management, LLC of Clymer for $100,000.
Bryan and Kristy Sicisnano sold 175 Grubb Hill Road, Poland to Danielle Chase for $207,000.
Jeffrey and Stephanie Johnson sold 165 Longview Ave., Ellicott to Chad and Karlee Donikowski for $485,000.
Sharon Tenpas sold 4325 Leach Hill Road, Ellington to the Donald L. Steward and Patricia P. Steward Family Trust for $280,000.
Frank and Angela Smith sold 46 Price Ave., Ellicott to Bradley Vilella, and Stephen and Pamela Piazza for $149,350.
KeyBank, NA sold 54 Broadhead Ave., Jamestown to Jaime Day for $44,500.
Roberta Elder sold 11 Main St., Sinclairville and an additional parcel on Main Street to APIF-New York, LLC of Foster City, Calif. for $668,416.
Ezra and John Weise sold a parcel on Honeysette Road, Chautauqua town to Andrew Luba for $10,000.
Thomas and Michele Lunz sold 239 Connecticut Ave., Jamestown to John and Diane Gatto for $155,000.
Deborah Kujawa sold 3 North Meadow Lane, Carroll to Mack Eadon Mikula and Addysen Arlene Tanner for $171,000.
Deerview, LLC of Jamestown sold a parcel on Route 430, Ellery to Anne Stover and Timothy Kackley for $110,000.
Chautauqua Inns, LTD of Mayville sold 177 W. Lake Road, Mayville to Lawndale Estates, LLC of Erie, Pa. for $166,350.
Robert and Susan Centa sold 6483 Sandalwood Lane, Chautauqua town to Tracy Colvin for $590,000.
Usiel Fuentes sold 2777 Rt. 394, North Harmony to Joseph Federico for $145,000.
James Dispense sold 11 Berry St., Fredonia to R&K Rei, LLC of Brocton for $53,500.
S&T of WNY, LLC of Jamestown sold five parcels on Foote Ave., Jamestown to Andrew Swanson for $65,000.
Frank Alessi sold 12255 Alleghany Road, Hanover to Kody Wagner for $155,000.
Frank Solares sold 744 Grant Ave., Dunkirk to Emily Spielman and Jordan Helt Spielman for $159,000.
The executors of the Estate of David Henning Swanson sold 111 Springdale Ave., Jamestown to Jeffrey Oleshak for $75,000.
The Andres Family Trust sold 22 Parkside St., Mayville to Brian and Kristen Peglowski for $340,000.
Kenneth Davis sold a parcel on Washington Street, Harmony to Andrew Lee and Brenda Yaneth Espitia Monsalve for $29,000.
N&M Properties of Dunkirk NY, LLC of Dunkirk sold 69 W. Fifth St., Dunkirk to Oscar Gonzalez for $66,950.
Scott Hannon, Shawn Hannon, Shavonne Kruszynski, and Mark and Stacey Hannon sold 71 Newton St., Jamestown to Kyle McIntyre and Ashley Benge for $158,900.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Betty Foster sold 9178 Walden Road, Pomfret to Paige Winford and Susan Lanning for $275,000.
George Duncan sold 22 Valmeere St., Falconer to Justin Casel for $20,000.
Joseph and Joan Appleyard sold Condominium Unit No. E-7, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua town to Jaye Roseborough for $250,000.
Mary Jane Thompson sold 5480 Johnson Road, Ripley to Andrew and Amanda Reiner for $80,000.
Beatrice Eccles, Randy Ordines, Diana Ordines, Brian Eccles, and Lauralynn Eccles sold 201 James St., Falconer to Brooke Andrews for $155,000.
David Bourne Jr. sold two parcels on McKinley Road, Westfield to Andrew Putnam for $174,000.
David Jr. and Linda Bourne sold three parcels on McKinley Road, Westfield to Andrew Putnam for $116,000.
Kurt and Pamela White sold 9247 Ravlin Hill Road, and three other parcels on Ravlin Hill and Bush roads, French Creek, were sold to 4 Jacks Dairy, LLC for $1,472,000. The parcels total around 150 acres.
Ronald Hammel sold 1945 Waits Corners Road, Clymer to Ernie Bender for $150,000.
Linda Blodgett and Randall Grant sold 60 East Courtney St., Dunkirk to 527 Deer Street, LLC of Dunkirk for $90,000.
The Charles Family Irrevocable Asset Protection Trust sold a parcel on Southwestern Drive, Jamestown to Matthew and Kaitlyn Copley for $32,000.
U.S. Bank National Association sold 5965 Niobe Road, Harmony to Wayne Schleicher, Melinda Schleicher and Steven Moore for $50,900.
The Peller Lake Trust sold 6007 Tinkertown Road, Chautauqua town to The Stephen F. Messinger Trust and The Claire L. Messinger Trust for $2,912,750.
Walkers Fruit Farms, LLC of Sheridan sold a parcel on Newell Road, Sheridan to Solo Grazia Holdings, LLC of Sheridan for $75,000.
Michael Muscarella sold 2059 Clymer-Sherman Road, Charlotte to Marvin Troyer for $131,600.
Elizabeth Homan, Molly Flynn, and Karin Flynn sold 315 Oak St., Lakewood to Derek Hosier for $210,000.
Anne Tahamont sold 5 Drake Ave., Silver Creek to Bruce Tahamont for $150,000.




