Breaking News
Top stories

Motion, With Only GOP Backing, Opposes Moving Elections

By Gregory Bacon 3 min read
Pictured are members of the Chautauqua County Legislature. P-J photo by Gregory Bacon

Chautauqua County's Republican lawmakers are going on record opposing moving elections to even-numbered years.

Their position is without Democratic support.

During last week's county Legislature meeting, lawmakers voted 14-4 in support of a motion urging Gov. Kathy Hochul to veto Election Law A.04282B-S.3505B. The bill would move town and county elections to even years, when there are presidential or gubernatorial races.

The proposal has already been passed by the state Senate and Assembly.

Motions have no legal authority but are designed to give the position of a governing body. In Chautauqua County, motions by the legislature need two-thirds support, or 13 votes.

The county Legislature has 15 Republican members and four Democratic members. On Wednesday, Legislator Dan Pavlock, R-Sinclairville was absent. The remaining 14 Republican legislators voted in favor of the motion.

The motion states, "by forcing local elections to compete against national and state-level campaigns, this legislation will decrease voters' attention to important local issues and deprive local candidates of appropriate platforms to explain their stance on issues."

The proposal would not affect certain local posts such as county district attorney, which are held on odd-numbered years under terms of the state constitution.

Because of this, county Republican Election Commissioner Brian Abram said previously this change won't save any money because they will still have to staff polls the same level as even years.

Legislator Terry Niebel, R-Sheridan, was the Republican election commissioner before Abram. He said he believes this will cost counties more money because of the need for more absentee ballots, and the likelihood that Chautauqua County won't be able to print its ballot in-house. "I've seen some dumb legislation come out of Albany; this is among the dumbest I've ever seen," he said.

Legislator Tom Nelson, D-Jamestown, agreed that it may not save money; however, he believes it will increase voter participation. "Voter turnout can fluctuate on many things, but there is a persistent pattern of low participation in local elections," he said.

Nelson noted that in Chautauqua County, about 33% of registered voters participate in local elections versus 67% in the latest presidential election. "Twice as many are turning out in those (presidential race) years," he said.

Niebel said he believes more races there are to vote on at once, the less likely voters are going to choose in each election. "Studies have shown that the larger the ballot, the more ballot fatigue you have. As you go across the ballot more people drop off and don't vote for positions at the end of the ballot," he said.

Legislator Susan Parker, D-Fredonia, disagreed. "The participation in the general election more than justifies the difference in the voting," she said.

Parker, Nelson, and Democratic legislators Bob Bankoski of Dunkirk and Billy Torres all voted against the motion.

A copy of the motion will be sent to Hochul.

Her office has not stated if she is in favor or against moving local elections to even numbered years.

Starting at /week.