Trending
The 2023 Jamestown budget has got some members of the City Council tightening their belts and looking at various purchasing requests with a fine-toothed comb.
At issue is the lease of a 2023 Chevrolet Trailblazer for Mayor Eddie Sundquist totaling more than $12,204 from Shults Auto Group. The purchase resolution was passed Monday by a vote of 5-4 in favor of the lease.
Voting no were council members Marie Carrubba, Andrew Faulkner, Kim Ecklund and Randy Daversa.
"It's a tough time to lease a vehicle for a mayor candidate when, I'll be honest with you, I think we need to look in budget time at all the vehicles that we have in the fleet and in lease," Ecklund said. "And if they (Shults) would have extended it until the end of the year to allow us to do that in budget time that probably would have been the best option."
Ecklund, a Republican, is running for mayor against Sundquist, a Democrat.
Those in favor of the lease purchase also voiced their position during Monday's council meeting.
"So, Shults was nice enough to construct this lease and hold this lease, so the mayor's vehicle would be a lower lease payment. So, the way it was explained to me was, 'No, we can't extend it,'" said Jeff Russell, R-At Large. "I'm in favor of the mayor having a car."
Russell went on to explain that the use of the mayor's vehicle for official use can be monitored and supervised.
"I was a policeman for 20 years, and for 20 years I had a GPS device in my patrol car. My supervisors knew where I was at," Russell said. "If there are concerns about misuse of this vehicle, then a GPS unit could be installed in the car to track its use."
It isn't the first time some members of the council have raised issues with the vehicle lease.
In December 2020, Ecklund questioned approval for the lease of Sundquist's Chevrolet Equinox. Ecklund said city officials didn't learn about the lease until budget deliberations, which started in October. She said the issue of whether Sundquist followed the city's procurement policy "gets tricky" because the lease was done by the Jamestown Urban Renewal Agency (JURA) and signed by Crystal Surdyk, city development director. The change from the former mayor's vehicle to the newer vehicle was officially approved after the lease was actually signed.
"Anytime there is a lease, it has to be approved by a body -- either the council or JURA," Ecklund said.
"This year, we have offered to be more transparent about it and we put it in the mayor's office budget. We shifted the cost away from JURA to the city's side," Sundquist said at the time. "It's not a strange thing for the mayor to have a vehicle. I thought it was strange the mayor's office vehicle continued to stay under JURA. We wanted to be more transparent to shift the cost to where the use is coming from."
Some council members then wanted to cut the lease out of the 2021 budget altogether, though decided against doing so by a 5-4 vote after some council members said the city would be hurt by leaving the lease early.