Resident Urges Council To Consider Climate Pledge Ramifications
Trending
John Zabrodsky, a local resident and member of the Manufacturers Association of the Southern Tier, urged city officials to consider every aspect of the New York State Climate Smart Communities pledge during Monday's City Council meeting.
Zabrodsky referenced a previous article in The Post-Journal regarding the city administration's proposal for the City Council to approve the adoption of the New York State Climate Smart Community pledge.
If adopted, Jamestown would pledge to plan and set goals for climate action, decrease the use of energy, build a climate smart community, implement climate smart land usage, transition to clean or renewable energy sources, support the innovation of a green economy, utilize climate smart management of materials, enhance the resilience of the Jamestown community to climate change and provide information and inspiration for the public to participate in an evolving process of climate action.
"This is truly a mouthful and a monumental pledge to technologies and policies that have not been developed or vetted at the national or the state level," Zabrodsky said. "Our community, city and county are fortunate to have approximately 20% of its workforce employed with jobs in manufacturing."
According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Zabrodsky said that the five counties of Western New York, including Chautauqua, Cattaraugus, Erie, Niagara and Allegheny, account for $26,814,000,000 worth of manufacturing shipments.
Zabrodsky explained that Chautauqua County's manufacturing output is estimated at $5.1 billion, accounting for 19% of Western New York's total output. He compared Chautauqua County's manufacturing output to Erie County's output, which is roughly 59% of Western New York's total output. Zabrodsky said it is "truly remarkable" that Chautauqua County's manufacturing output is only three times less than Erie County's output despite Erie County having almost eight times the population of Chautauqua County.
"Those jobs count, and those jobs are well-paying," he said. "Much of the county's manufacturing base is in and around Jamestown and the Jamestown BPU service territory for electric, water, wastewater district heating, district cooling and solid waste. As a resident and property taxpayer for the city, a business owner, an employer with its main operation in the city, and a member of the Manufacturers Association of the Southern Tier, I'm asking you to continue to study all of the ramifications of what such a pledge as this Climate Smart Community would entail."
From his perspective, Zabrodsky warned City Council members that committing to a pledge that involves "less than defined policies" seems hasty. He suggested that with the rapid change of technology and shifting policies at the state and national level, the policies outlined in the Climate Smart Communities pledge could change in the near future.
During his public comments, Zabrodsky specifically addressed Mayor Eddie Sundquist and City Councilwoman Kim Ecklund, R-At large, regarding the upcoming election for mayor.
"You'll have many difficult choices to make depending on which of you will be successful in winning the election for mayor this fall," he said. "This will be one of many. It will be important to hear from you directly on this matter, so that as constituents, we can make informed choices."
Zabrodsky claimed that if the Jamestown community wants to grow in the future and expand its employment base, the city will not be able to restrict energy consumption, place restrictions on utility companies such as the BPU or "throttle" manufacturing companies and manufacturing employment in the region.
"This will not be part of the solution," he said. "Again, members of City Council I urge you to continue your study of this proposal. It is vastly premature to bring this to any sort of resolution or vote."