Jury Gets Post Case After Closing Arguments

OBSERVER Photo by Gregory Bacon Dustin Post is pictured walking to his seat in Chautauqua County Court Thursday morning.

MAYVILLE – The fate of a northern Chautauqua County man is now in the hands of a jury.

Thursday afternoon, County Court Judge David Foley charged the jury to decide whether they believe 27-year-old Dustin Post should be found guilty or not guilty with regard to the nine indictments against him, all involving sexual misconduct or attempted sexual misconduct against children.

The defense gave its closing statement first, which took about an hour.

Public Defender Nathaniel Barone criticized the video made of Post with officers at the State Police headquarters. “That’s not good enough in a court of law,” he said, adding, “There’s reasons why people lie.”

Barone argued that the prosecution didn’t demonstrate corroboration. “This is when our justice system is put to the test so innocent men and women aren’t convicted for something they haven’t done,” he said.

Barone noted there wasn’t forensic evidence or third party witnesses.

In terms of the victims, he questioned inconsistencies made between what Post said on the video and what the young girls reported in court. He felt those inconsistencies should require the jury to throw out their testimonies. “Otherwise someone is being convicted of something they didn’t do,” he said.

He called on jurors to “have the strength to set aside your emotions” and find his client not guilty.

The only objection the prosecution made was when Barone questioned the Child Advocacy Program where many of the children stated for the first time that they had been abused. Judge David Foley permitted the statement made by Barone but told him to “move on.”

Barone also noted there were several years between the time of the alleged events and when they were reported.

After Barone, District Attorney Jason Schmidt gave the closing for the prosecution. He spoke for about an hour and 10 minutes.

Schmidt reminded the jury that there were audio and video statements of Post confessing what he had done, along with videos made by Post abusing his victims.

He noted that the investigators never made any promises but were calm and invited Post to share what had happened. “You need to decide if those were his words and if he gave them voluntary,” he said.

Along with the video evidence, Schmidt noted how several children and their mothers testified and what they shared generally matched up with what Post told investigators. He agreed that the timing or the specific acts weren’t exactly the same, but that should demonstrate that the children weren’t told what to say; they simply shared what they remembered.

Multiple times Barone objected to Schmidt’s closing, but for the most part Foley allowed Schmidt to make his points.

At one point Schmidt pulled out an art easel and paper pad, angling it for the jury to see the names of the victims and the crimes that were committed against them.

He detailed, using the children’s words, the type of sexual conduct each one of them endured.

He didn’t deny that the children took a while before sharing about what had happened to them, but said children don’t easily come forward with these times of incidents. “The issue is whether what they told you was true and accurate,” he said.

Schmidt also said the children have no reason to lie about what had happened. “Nothing developed at trial would suggest this,” he said.

Post was sentenced in February 2022 to 50 years in prison after being convicted on federal charges of production and possession of child pornography. He has remained in the Chautauqua County Jail for these charges involving several children. The trial began Thursday, Jan. 26.

This story will be updated following the jury’s actions.


Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper? *


Starting at $4.62/week.

Subscribe Today