Trending
Did Jamestown Mayor Eddie Sundquist follow the city's procurement policy when he leased a 2020 Chevrolet Equinox in July?
According to a couple members of the Jamestown City Council, the mayor didn't follow city policy.
Kim Ecklund, At-Large council woman and Finance Committee chairwoman, said anytime a city official spends more than $500, the purchase has to be voted on by the council. The lease of the Equinox from Ed Shults Chevrolet calls for a $291.84 payment for 36 months, which totals $10,506.
Ecklund said city officials didn't learn about the lease until budget deliberations, which started in October. She said the issue of whether Sundquist followed the city's procurement policy "gets tricky" because the lease was done by the Jamestown Urban Renewal Agency (JURA), which was singed by Crystal Surdyk, city development director. However, in the 2021 budget, the lease for the mayor's SUV is not a part of JURA's budget, but a line item for the mayor's office.
Ecklund said in 2019 during budget deliberations for the 2020 spending plan, some members of the council wanted to remove the mayor's car from the JURA budget. She said some council members want to give mileage funding to city officials, including the mayor, to use their own car instead of having the city lease vehicles.
"Anytime there is a lease, it has to be approved by a body -- either the council or JURA," Ecklund said.
Anthony Dolce, council president, said he knows the council didn't vote to approve the lease and he is unsure if JURA voted on it as well. The last time JURA board met was in April.
"It's a matter of interpretation, you could say. Normally it goes through JURA and voted on by JURA. I don't think it was done there either," he said.
Prior to approving the 2021 budget, council voted on whether to cut the vehicle lease out of next year's spending plan. The amendment vote failed by a 5 to 4 margin because some council members were worried about having to pay a penalty fee for breaking the lease.
The lease contract with Shults states early termination may lead to charges of several thousands of dollars, but doesn't specify an exact amount.
"It was determined by the majority of council that the lease was already signed and it would cost money to get out of it," Dolce said.
According to Sundquist, the city's procurement policy was followed to lease the vehicle. He said the city requested bids for proposal, receiving five, with Shults' being the lowest bid. He said the only thing being done differently in leasing the vehicle in the 2021 budget is that the cost of the lease is a line item for the mayor's office instead of being a part of JURA's budget.
"This year, we have offered to be more transparent about it and we put it in the mayor's office budget. We shifted the cost away from JURA to the city's side," he said. "It's not a strange thing for the mayor to have a vehicle. I thought it was strange the mayor's office vehicle continued to stay under JURA. We wanted to be more transparent to shift the cost to where the use is coming from."
Sundquist said the lease of the vehicle needs to be approved by the JURA board and not the council. He said JURA is scheduled to meet next month and will vote on the vehicle lease.
"It could still be approved by the JURA board because it's a replacement lease," he said. "There was already a vehicle there prior to me coming on board, so JURA can approve it the next time it meets."