811 N. Main St., Jamestown was sold in October for $850,000. In 2022, when Rite Aid was operating out of that location, it was purchased for nearly $3 million.

A former drug store building has been sold at less than a third of its value three years ago.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the sales from Oct. 1-6.

During this time period, OFP Wagradol NY, LLC sold 811 Main St., Jamestown to Southern Chautauqua Federal Credit Union for $850,000.

This is the former Rite Aid building.

In September, Southern Chautauqua Federal Credit Union Chief Executive Officer John Felton told The Post-Journal that they were purchasing the former Rite Aid building.

The CEO added that the new building will be a full-service branch with office space for a few departments, and 20 employees in the back office.

“We will also have a community conference room available to the public, much like the community room located in Lakewood, our corporate office,” Felton said. “The Jamestown community room will be designed to accommodate 20 to 25 people.”

Felton noted that a September 2026 opening date is projected.

The building had been worth a lot more just three years ago.

In April, 2022 OFP Wagradol NY, LLP purchased the property from Orion Development RA XXXI, LLC for $2,948,763.

Including the sale previously mentioned, there were 17 sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:

– 41 Vincent Ave, Chautauqua Institution sold for $930,000.

– Unit No. 2-B, South Lake Drive Condominium, Chautauqua Institution sold for $829,500.

– 116 West Terrace Ave., Lakewood sold for $580,000.

– 2397 Sunnyside Road, Mina sold for $539,900.

– Home No. E-5, NorthShore at Chautauqua, 20 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution sold for $450,000.

– 2911 Bentley Ave., Ellicott sold for $435,000.

– Unit Number 8237, Canterbury Woods I Condominium, 8237 Canterbury Drive, French Creek sold for $395,000.

– 12836 Iola Drive, Hanover sold for $350,000.

– 6436 Galloway Road, Chautauqua town sold for $310,000.

– 4 Brewster Place, Westfield sold for $300,000.

– 2777 South Roberts Road, Sheridan sold for $290,000.

– 7181 Ridge Road, Stockton sold for $282,000.

– 11824 Old Main Road, Hanover sold for $260,000.

– Condominium Unit No. 8 in Bayberry Landing Condominium, 5301 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town sold $255,000.

– 3985 Falconer Kimball Stand Road, Ellicott sold for $254,000.

– 12 W. Terrace Ave., Lakewood sold for $250,000.

Overall, from Oct. 1-6 there were 65 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:

OCT. 1-3

Richard and Karen Cleveland sold 891 Southside Ave., Cherry Creek to Troy Ewing for $216,000.

Elaine Kostyszyn sold a parcel on Dybka Road, Cherry Creek to Frank Nowicki for $50,000.

The administrator of the Estate of John Cournean Jr. sold 1895 Emory Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Lindsey Dingman for $94,000.

Stephen and Tiffany Jusko sold a parcel on Hahn Road, Pomfret to Michael and Natalie Hubert for $120,000.

The executor of the Estate of Peter Flagg sold 5465 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Kathryn Guest and Daniel Gleason for $109,900.

Bruce Anderson sold 22 Kingsbury St., Jamestown to Claudia Sanchez for $12,000.

Paul and Brenda Tabone sold 3564 Brainard Road, Arkwright to Matthew Poummit for $79,900.

Andrew and Stephanie Arndt sold Condominium Unit No. 8 in Bayberry Landing Condominium, 5301 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town for $255,000.

Ronald and Courtney Hickox sold 4199B Bruyer Road, Stockton to Herb Cobbe for $78,500.

James IV and Minerva Robb sold 305 Canary St., Dunkirk to Fernando Alicia Acevedo and Yasaira Castaner Rivera for $115,000.

R&R Developers sold a parcel on Hunt and Grandview Road, Busti to Nazan Acik for $48,000.

The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of Marvin Waterman sold 2777 South Roberts Road, Sheridan to Tanya and Brewster II Bayles for $290,000.

Douglas and Kim Mann sold 3985 Falconer Kimball Stand Road, Ellicott to Dakota Gardner and Sarah Hanlon for $254,000.

14 South Lake Drive, LLC of Cleveland Heights, Ohio sold Unit No. 2-B, South Lake Drive Condominium, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Charles and Suzanne Messing for $829,500.

Curtis Burris sold 4 Brewster Place, Westfield to Robb Jr and Christina Shipley for $300,000.

Robin Carpenter sold 31 Central Ave., Brocton to Caleb and Riley Lokietek for $127,500.

The Mary H. Loftus Revocable Trust sold Home No. E-5, NorthShore at Chautauqua, 20 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Jacob III and Lauren Burkhart for $450,000.

The Janice M. Schultz Revocable Family Trust sold 33-35 Elm St., Westfield to Darlene and Matthew Golibersuch for $150,000.

Deanna Kmiotek sold 12836 Iola Drive, Hanover, to Russel and Erika Marranca for $350,000.

Steve Fowler sold 2916 Bentley Ave., Ellicott to Professional Hospitality, LLC of Jamestown for $20,000.

The trustees of the J&R Trust sold 41 Vincent Ave, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to the D&K Trust for $930,000.

Kay Hitchcock sold 883 Bentley Hill Road, Ellington to Johnnie and Rachel Raber for $110,000.

Ronald and Constance Hall sold 16 Barnes St., Mayville to Elizabeth Pardue for $110,000.

Karen Swanson sold 416 Robin St., Dunkirk to Dale Lombardo and Kylee Botticello for $137,800.

Michael Nagel sold Unit No. B2, Glen Park Condominium, 4-8 Morris Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Patricia Holmwood and Suzanne Pritchard for $225,000.

Andrew and Patricia Gallant sold 7181 Ridge Road, Stockton to Courtney Smith and Todd Griepentrog for $282,000.

James and Nora Nealon sold 208 East Elmwood Ave., Falconer to Brandi and Brittany Beard for $115,000.

Michael Cardoza sold 1007 N. Main St., Jamestown to James Whitehead for $35,000.

Russell and Judith Sprickman sold Unit Number 8237, Canterbury Woods I Condominium, 8237 Canterbury Drive, French Creek to David Ott for $395,000.

Kevin Newman sold 2911 Bentley Ave., Ellicott to Joseph Beccalori and Kimberly Field for $435,000.

The John S. and Judith L. Revocable Living Trust sold 6436 Galloway Road, Chautauqua town to Julie and Clayton Murphy for $310,000.

The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of Harry Fackelman sold a parcel on Pickard Road, Ellery to Doug Hillerby for $6,100.

OCT. 6

Mark Wroblewski sold 9288 Stateline Road, French Creek to David and Sandra McCray for $55,000.

Michael Young sold 502 Brigham Road, Dunkirk to Big Three Holdings, LLC of Liverpool, NY for $37,500.

Mary Prather sold 8715 Knowlton Road, Clymer to Phillip Johnson for $90,000.

William Mackey sold 1111 Rt. 5 & 20, Hanover to Brian and Tracy Schottin for $220,000.

Tracey Brunecz sold 7236 Rogerville Road, Westfield to Randy Hosler for $224,000.

OFP Wagradol NY, LLC of Bloomfield Hills, Mich. sold 811 Main St., Jamestown to Southern Chautauqua Federal Credit Union for $850,000.

Michael and Carolyn Douglas sold 2397 Sunnyside Road, Mina to Michael and Aubree Obrycki for $539,900.

The Dr. Rosemarie Reinecke Stoiantschewsky Living Trust sold two parcels on Rt. 83, Arkwright, totaling 53 acres, to Lyle Milliman for $145,000.

Silver Baker Properties, LLC of Silver Creek to 11824 Old Main Road, Hanover to David Kohlbacher for $260,000.

REO Trust 2025-NR1 of Chicago, Illinois sold 3394 Stone Quarry Road, Sheridan to Claire Stokes for $48,000.

Kirk and Brooke Kelly sold 116 West Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Colonial 16, LLC of Lakewood for $580,000.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Thomas Green sold 12 W. Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Kirk Kelly for $250,000.

Donald and Sara Henderson sold 2365 Carlson Road, Kiantone to Arthur and Concetta Kennedy for $180,000.

Shane and Patricia Wassink sold a 21.4 acre parcel on Clymer-Corry Road, Clymer to Jonathan Hostetler for $70,000.

Harvey King sold 385 Einink Road, Clymer to Cole and Elizabeth Gleason for $30,000.

Jonathan Cairo sold 174 Barrett Ave., Jamestown to Brock One Services, LLC of Kissimmee, Fla. for $48,000.

Andria Meeder sold 4124 Webster Road, Pomfret to Valerie Raynor for $80,000.

Michael Hetrick and Jill Jackson sold 36 Pennsylvania Ave., Jamestown to Zachary and Gail Tatoczenko for $85,000.

Muchell Vahl sold 9414 Bailey Hill Road, Mina to William Himelein for $80,000.