Sales Include Ellicott Oil Change Building

NS Retail Holdings, LLC purchased 995 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott for about $2.2 million. That’s where Take 5 Oil Change is located. The company also owns a Dollar General in Gerry. Photo by Gregory Bacon
The building of a newly constructed oil change business in the southern end of the county has a new owner.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from April 25-30.
During this time period, Quattro Jamestown, LLC sold 995 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to NS Retail Holdings, LLC for $2,218,750. This is a Take 5 Oil Change location that is currently in operation. It was first proposed in 2023.
The site, located in West Ellicott just prior to entering the village of Lakewood, was previously home to Pizza Hut and, most recently, Honest John’s Pizzeria.
NS Retail Holdings, LLC also owns the building where a Dollar General was recently constructed in Gerry.
Including the sale previously mentioned, from April 25-30 there were four sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 4533 Miller Road, Ellery sold for $477,500.
– 12037 Aldrich Road, Sheridan sold for $400,000.
– 11357 Hanover Road, Hanover sold for $385,000.
Overall, from April 25-30 there were 58 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
APRIL 25
Leigh Jordan sold 497 Willard St., Jamestown to Jason and Leigh Jordan for $22,525.
Quattro Jamestown, LLC of Oak Brook, Ill. sold 995 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to NS Retail Holdings, LLC of Dallas, Texas for $2,218,750.
Lawrence and Mary Knoll, Katherine Maggs and Peggy Kifner sold 11357 Hanover Road, Hanover to Andrew Maggs and Pamela Pulinski for $385,000.
Gail Aaberg and Ronald Thompson sold 12293 Alleghany Road, Silver Creek to Jaylee Willis-Kosnik and Nathan Locking for $204,000.
KLF Enterprises LTD of Chagrin Falls, Ohio sold 4 Crystal Ave., Lakewood to Quinn Payne for $135,000.
Erin Carroll sold 26 Middlesex Drive, Fredonia to Cartus Financial Corp. for $235,000. Cartus Financial Corp. sold that same address to Lori and William Sliwa for the same price.
Philip Gabriel, Travis Gabriel, Tyler Gabriel and Susan Gabriel sold a parcel on Bush Road, French Creek to Christopher and Roberta Park for $31,982.
Mariana Eckholm sold 42 Metcalf Ave., Ellicott to Brittany Davies for $134,000.
Philip Gabriel, Travis Gabriel, Tyler Gabriel and Susan Gabriel sold a parcel on Bush Road, French Creek to Leonard Jr. and Mary Jo Neckers for $45,848.
APRIL 28-30
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Galen Pellish sold 7185 Lewis Road, Charlotte to Ronald Pepin Jr. for $6,000.
Sue Mead sold 13 North Gazelle St., Dunkirk to Callie Rolls for $56,000.
Joseph Sedlak sold 5846 Rt. 380, Stockton to Anthony and Elizabeth Ferrieira for $75,000.
MK River Holdings, LLC of Kennedy sold 5 Cowing St., Jamestown to Bryan Greenawalt for $63,490.
Paul Ruper sold 4533 Miller Road, Ellery to Ronald and Elizabeth Abbatoy for $477,500.
Brian and Monica Sudbrink sold 36 McDonough St., Dunkirk to Jamie Hemenger for $145,000
Allen and Lena Miller sold 8422 E. Main St., Clymer to Paul and Rebecca Weaver for $40,000.
Mervin and Betsy Byler sold a parcel on East Main Street, Clymer to Melvin and Emma Miller for $100,000.
John Munch sold 12037 Aldrich Road, Sheridan to Joseph and Amanda Mox for $400,000.
Erik Stornes sold 594 Route 394, Poland to Megan Goodwill for $155,000.
Richard Davies sold 704 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to the Richard E. Davies Irrevocable Trust for $35,000.
Donald Moore sold 230 Forest Ave., Jamestown to Svetlana and Nikolay Bosovets for $20,000.
Larry Barmore sold 341 Crossman St., Jamestown to Tre Frank for $95,000.
Mallory and Joan Green sold a parcel on Swede Road, Harmony to Michael and Kathleen Abbate for $24,000.
A referee for the administratrix of the Estate of Mark and Patricia Duncanson ,Trevor Wilson, Lester Wilson, Brian Taylor and Bubba Wilson sold 25 Wicks Ave., Ellicott to Kickstart Properties, LLC for $67,000.