×

Real Estate Sales Include Mayville Area Cottages, Dunkirk Storefront

423-437 Central Ave., Dunkirk was sold in November for $200,000. P-J photo by Gregory Bacon

A popular cottage on Chautauqua Lake has new owners, but keeping the same name.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Nov. 13-20.

Irwin Bay Cottages and Vacation Rentals, LLC of Mayville sold 5090 W. Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Irwin Bay Cottages, LLC of Mayville for $950,000.

On Nov. 18, in a Facebook post, Irwin Bay Cottages announced it had new owners. “As the sun sets on one beautiful chapter, it rises on another. We’re delighted to introduce ourselves as the new caretakers of the cherished Irwin Bay Cottages tradition. We are the Newell Family, and we’re honored to continue the legacy that Julie has so lovingly nurtured over the years,” they wrote.

Also during that time period, 423-427 Central Avenue, LLC of Tonawanda sold 423-427 Central Ave., Dunkirk to 427 Central, LLC of East Aurora for $200,000. Allan B. Steinberg signed as the manager of 423-427 Central Ave., LLC. Earlier in 2023, Steinberg sold the Colburn Block on Central Avenue, Dunkirk as well as the former Carriage House Warehouse in Fredonia.

Irwin Bay Cottages outside of Mayville is operating under new ownership. P-J photo by Gregory Bacon

At 423 Central Ave. is Deborah Ferrer Design Studio. The business opened Nov. 17, the same day as the sale. According to the design studio’s website, Ferrer has been working in the construction industry for over 20 years, specializing in residential kitchen and bathroom design.

At 427 Central Ave., Dunkirk is Leghicie Lashes, an eyelash salon. A grand opening for the salon was held on April 20, 2023. Before Leghicie Lashes, Studio Beauty Salon was located there.

Including the previously mentioned transaction, from Nov. 11-20 there were nine sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:

— 3540-3541 Ross St., North Harmony sold for $895,000.

— 5 Merrill Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, sold for $500,000.

— 3661 Pleasant Ave., Ellery sold for $480,000.

— 3584 Mary Ellen Drive, Ellery sold for $406,250.

— 1240 Mee Road, Poland sold for $295,000.

— 287 Ivy St., Jamestown sold for $254,900.

— 446 King Road, Hanover sold for $250,000.

— 7522 Rt. 474, Clymer sold for $250,000.

Overall, from Nov. 11-20 there were 126 transactions. The full list of sales over $1 is as follows:

U.S. Bank Trust National Association sold 380 S. Main St., Jamestown to Prideful Property Group, LLC of Jamestown for $15,300.

A referee for John Butcher Jr. sold 11169 Mixer Road, Hanover to Plaza Home Mortgage Inc. of Mount Laurel, NJ for $114,565.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Mary Grow sold 48 Ellis Ave., Jamestown to William Jr. and Tia Mizell for $139,000.

Colby Garza sold 115 S. Roberts Road, Dunkirk to Joseph Santiago for $10,000.

David and Bonnie Gray sold a parcel on E. Elmwood Avenue, Ellicott to Darrick and Elizabeth Kight for $12,500.

Ann Fafinski-Mason sold 82 Jamestown St., Sinclairville to Bryan King for $169,000.

Suzanne Rammelt sold 8449 West Main Road, Westfield to George LaPorte Jr. for $130,500.

Catherine Bullinger sold 142 Sea Lion Drive, Mayville to Robert Schrader and Kacie Johnson for $218,500.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Jeffrey Church and Judith Church sold 4812 Herrick Road, Gerry to Kody Hoth for $100,000.

Terry and Nancy LeBaron sold 2916 Swanson Road, Ellicott to Michael and Michelle Vandenburg for $180,000.

Julia Kinney sold 8 Susan Court, Fredonia to Kenneth and Martha Schmitt for $97,500.

Jason Tyler McKay McEntire and Molly Paige McEntire sold 23 School St., Panama, to Cari Lynn Kinney for $245,000.

TKO Properties, LLC of Jamestown sold 287 Ivy St., Jamestown to Jason and Taylor Seiberg for $254,900.

Susan Gabriel sold 2449 Elam St., Ellicott to Anthony Mercado for $50,350.

Michele Howell and Christine Bartolo sold 1 Houston Court, Celoron to Brett Thompson for $130,000.

Daniel Rizzo sold 3317 West Oak Hill Road, Ellicott to Brett Carlson for $239,900.

Glenn Loser and Tina Elderkin-Loser sold 7013 Rt. 60, Stockton to Richard Rusiniak for $130,000.

Emily Clapp sold 182 Water St., Fredonia to Olivia Kaltenbach for $150,000.

Thomas Fenton sold a parcel on Ivory Road, Carroll to Chad and Wendy Allison for $3,000.

Albert and Jean Foley sold 5332 Lakeside Boulevard, Van Buren Bay, town of Pomfret, to Elizabeth Foley for $200,000.

Jeffrey and Amber Mazany sold 771 Main St., Dunkirk to Benjamin Charles Fuller-Braley for $104,000.

NYSARC, Inc. of Jamestown sold two parcels on Glenwood Avenue, Silver Creek to Scott Gustavson for $33,500.

Lee Van Leaven sold a parcel on Ohio Street, Irving, town of Hanover, to Phillip Corda for $21,000.

Raymond Hauser sold 147 Union St., Westfield to Arthur and Kim Erbacher for $7,500.

The executors of the Last Will and Testament of Mary Ann Nordstrom sold a parcel on Van Buren Point, Portland to Jeffrey McVeigh and Srinivas Sai A. Kondapalli for $115,000.

Allen Jackson Smith sold 119 W. Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Elizabeth Morando for $240,000.

Alicia Mae Archie sold 53 Liberty St., Jamestown to Katherine Bush for $81,600.

Geraldine Lyle sold 2963 West Sheridan Road, Sheridan to Thomas and Angelica Dawes for $103,900.

Irwin Bay Cottages and Vacation Rentals, LLC of Mayville sold 5090 W. Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Irwin Bay Cottages, LLC of Mayville for $950,000.

Kathleen Colby sold 28 Fairfield Ave., Jamestown to Leslie and Carolyn Bennett for $61,000. Leslie and Carolyn Bennett sold that parcel to P3 Estate Holdings, LLC of Jupiter, Fla. for $130,000.

Thomas and Summer Przybylak sold 8120 Bear Lake Road, Pomfret to Amanda Schwartz for $148,000.

Kenneth and Maryanne Balling sold 8126 Bear Lake Road, Pomfret to Thomas and Summer Przybylak for $290,000.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Catherine Barone sold 3866 Gerry Levant Road, Ellicott to Walter Troyer Jr. for $210,000.

Royal Housing, LLC of Jamestown sold 304 and 218 West Eighth St., Jamestown to Hugh and Susan Karp for $55,000.

Donna Gasper sold 446 King Road, Hanover to Jessica Rappa and Nickolas O’Neill for $250,000.

Clifton and Co. Property Group, LLC of Buffalo sold 163 Barrett St., 96 Water St. and 211 Newland Ave., Jamestown to Hugh and Susan Karp for $140,000.

Patricia Strong sold 27 Merchant Place, Falconer to Allegheny Property Holdings, Inc. of Jamestown for $89,000.

IBM Empire Holdings, LLC of Dover, Delaware sold 341 Foote Ave. and a parcel on Walnut Street to Velas Global, LLC of Hopewell Junction, NY for $42,000.

Margaret McKee Baughman sold 212 West Main St., Westfield to Carole Okey for $133,600.

Stanley Scheetz sold Timeshare Unit 8112, Week 19, Building I, The Seasons at Greenwood Forest Condominium, Canterbury Drive, French Creek to Gregory Taylor, Mary Beth Taylor, Jacob Taylor, and Laura Taylor for $1,250.

Last Peace Construction, LLC of Dewittville sold 621 Newland Ave., Jamestown to Dena Zeman for $65,000.

The Secretary of Housing and Urban Development of Philadelphia, Pa. sold 74 McDaniel Ave., Jamestown to Phillip Darlington for $44,551.

Douglas Howser sold 8388 West Forest Ave., Portland to Robert Burgess for $35,000.

Britt Bridges sold 157 Lake Ave., Brocton to Renee Matteliano for $200,000.

Jeslyanne Laboy Hernandez sold 904 N. Main St., Jamestown to Caleb Barnes for $55,000.

Maynard Bunn Jr. sold 3555 Lake St., Ellicott to Michelle Sabadasz and Hollis Kaiser Group, LLC of Lancaster, NY for $160,000.

Daniel and Elsie Miller sold 7522 Rt. 474, Clymer to Mark and Erma Miller for $250,000.

Anthony Trippi sold 514 Plover St., Dunkirk to Dorothy Hill for $45,000.

Abdulla M. Abuhamra sold 24 Crown St., Jamestown to Charlie Daniel Benitez and Ana Ivette Garcia Ortiz for $4,000.

The executors of the Last Will and Testament of Izetta H. Ayling sold 5932 Magnolia Stedman Road, North Harmony to Samantha Piazza for $55,000.

Gregory and Carla Schaap sold a parcel on Denslow Avenue, Ellicott to Douglas Diver II for $220,000.

423-427 Central Avenue, LLC of Tonawanda sold 423-427 Central Ave., Dunkirk to 427 Central, LLC of East Aurora for $200,000.

U.S. Bank National Association sold 9435 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret to Brandy Cordova for $32,500.

Kathleen Grace sold 3584 Mary Ellen Drive, Ellery to Alexander and Katie Grace for $406,250.

James Johnson and Rondy Miller sold 542 Stowe St., Jamestown to Joseph Troche for $210,000.

Arlie and Shelly Quackenbush sold 11 Maple St., Celoron to Michael Christopher Bird for $100,000.

Jeffrey Passafaro, David Passafaro, Paula Passafaro, Ronald Passafaro and Marian McGraw sold 135 Central Ave., Fredonia to Crystal Rivera for $225,000.

David Civilette sold 777 Washington Ave., Dunkirk to Justin Abbott for $140,000.

PPP Future Development, Inc. of Alexander, NY sold 4228 West Lake Road, Mayville to Samuel Bender for $155,000.

Kyle Morse and Mikinna Martin sold 33 North St., Panama to Bradley Rater for $165,000.

Gregory and Katherine O’Hara sold 3540-3541 Ross St., North Harmony to Steven and Lisa Olson for $895,000.

Scott Macey, Michelle Hickey, Mindy Michalek, and Michael Macey sold 1240 Mee Road, Poland to Cody Frey and Heather Hoden for $295,000.

A referee for Kimberly Myles sold 3545 Salisbury Road, Gerry to U.S. Bank National Association for $151,036.

Stephen O’Brien and Elizabeth Curtin-O’Brien sold 72 W. Fourth St., Dunkirk to Luz Gonzalez for $80,000.

Geovanny Moya and Flor Julissa Moya sold a parcel on Westminster Circle, Ellicott to Meredith MacTavish for $25,000.

Jamie Meder sold 166 Chautauqua St., Fredonia to Daniel Kline for $180,000.

Benjamin and Sandra Leichner sold 1004 Wigren Road, Carroll to Nicholas Spitzer for $6,000.

Stanley Scheetz sold Timeshare Unit 8122, Week 48, Building 2, The Seasons at Greenwood Forest Condominium, Canterbury Drive, French Creek, to Matthew and Leanne Fuetter for $1,500.

Shirley Caswell sold 510 E. Rt. 394, Poland, to Sherri Crouse for $120,000.

Thomas and Karen Wagner sold 5 Merrill Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Mitchell and Heather Overton for $500,000.

Charles Weber sold 29 Frew Run St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Joshua Eckert for $65,000.

Paul and Deborah Leachko sold 3661 Pleasant Ave., Ellery to Kyle and Stephanie Herron for $480,000.

Yvonne Bair sold 79 Newton Ave., Jamestown to Benjamin Gibson for $58,000.

Jason Genberg sold 42 Campbell Ave., Jamestown to Brandon Furlow for $149,999.

Suzanne Aldrich, Diane Hovey and Carol Nyberg sold 4865 West Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Benjamin Hartner for $155,000.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper? *
   

Starting at $4.62/week.

Subscribe Today