Breaking News
Local News

Former Diner Property, Nearby Land To Go Up For Sale

By Gregory Bacon 2 min read
The site of the former Mayville Diner and neighboring property will soon be marketed. P-J photo by Gregory Bacon

MAYVILLE -- The vacant property where the former Mayville Diner sat along with some nearby land will soon be up for sale.

During this week's Mayville Village Board meeting, officials talked about finding an agency to market the property at 7 West Chautauqua St.

In December, 2019, the diner was destroyed in a fire, started by Michael Ellis, who ran the restaurant at the time and destroyed it for the insurance money. He was arrested, pleaded guilty and was sentenced.

After the fire, the village paid for the clean-up of the property. The property ended up going to the county for back taxes. The county signed over the property to the village, with the agreement that they could cover their own costs and then split any profit from selling the property.

Mayor Rick Syper said the village so far has invested about $25,000 in the property.

During Tuesday's village board meeting, officials said it may be hard to market the property since there's limited parking. They suggested contacting the town of Chautauqua to see if they would like to sell some of their property that butts up against the diner property.

The issue was brought up the next day at the Chautauqua Town Board meeting.

"We have a lot of land around that property. We're not going to ever use it for anything, so why don't we work with the village to package those together to make a bigger parcel. Hopefully that will attract some business interest there," Councilman Scott Cummings said.

Town Supervisor Don Emhardt agreed. "I would not be opposed to selling the whole hill," he said, noting that the hill is difficult to mow and they would rather someone else take care of it.

Syper, who was at the town board meeting, said he has spoken with Mark Geise from the county's Industrial Development Agency and Economic Development, about possible firms to market the property.

Before the fire, the Mayville Diner was one of the only restaurants in the village that was open for breakfast and lunch.

Starting at /week.